The car accident
At around 18:30 on Thursday 14 March 2013, a car crashed into the back of a truck on Road 5 in Salfit Governorate, occupied Palestine. The driver and her 3 daughters were injured, one of them – seriously. The driver, Adva Biton, was going back to the illegal Israeli settler colony of Yakir when the accident occurred. She later claimed the accident was due to Palestinian youth throwing stones at her car. The driver of the truck, having testified immediately after the accident that he had pulled over because of a flat tyre, later changed his mind and said he had seen stones by the road.
There were no witnesses to the car accident. Nobody had seen any children or youth throwing stones that day.
In the early hours of Friday 15 March 2013, masked Israeli soldiers, some with attack dogs, stormed the village of Hares, which is close to Road 5. More than 50 soldiers broke the doors of the villagers’ houses, demanding the whereabouts of their teenage sons. Ten boys were arrested that night, blindfolded, handcuffed, and transferred to an unknown location. The families were not informed of their sons’ alleged wrongdoings.
Two days later, a second wave of violent arrests took place. At around 3 o’clock in the morning, the Israeli army, accompanied by the Shabak (the Israeli secret service), entered the homes of 3 Palestinian adolescents. They had a piece of paper with their names in Hebrew. After forcing all the family members into one room, taking away their phones so that they wouldn’t call for help, and interrogating them, the soldiers handcuffed their sons, all aged 16-17.
“Kiss and hug your mother goodbye,” a Shabak agent told one boy. “You may never see her again.”
A week later, Israeli army jeeps again entered the village and arrested several boys, who had just come back home from school. The soldiers lined all of them up, including a 6-year-old, and threatened at gunpoint their uncle who pleaded for the soldiers to at least release the youngest children. The army then randomly chose 3 boys, handcuffed them behind their backs, blindfolded them, and took them away. The families were not informed about either the allegations against their children, or their exact location.
In total, 19 boys from the neighbouring villages of Hares and Kifl Hares were arrested in relation to the settler car accident. None of them had previously had any history of stone-throwing. After violent interrogations, most of the minors were released, except for five, who remain in Megiddo, an Israeli adult prison.
These are the Hares Boys.
The arrested boys were subjected to a series of abuse and ill-treatment that accounts as torture. Upon detention, they were kept in solitary confinement for up to two weeks. One boy, since released, described his cell: a windowless hole 1m wide and 2m long; there was no mattress or blanket to sleep on; toilet facilities were dirty; the six lights were kept on continuously, leading to the boy losing track of the time of the day; the food made him feel ill. The boy was denied lawyer; he was interrogated violently three times during three days, and eventually released after found not guilty at the trial.
Other boys have also told their lawyers of very similar treatment. They “confessed” of stone-throwing after being repeatedly abused in prison and during interrogations.
The five boys from Hares are charged with 20 counts of attempted murder each, apparently 1 count for every alleged stone thrown at passing cars. The Israeli military prosecution insists that the boys consciously “intended to kill”; the boys can face the maximum punishment for attempted murder: 20 years to life imprisonment.
The prosecution’s case relies on the boys’ “confessions”, which have been obtained under torture, and 61 “witnesses,” some of which claim that their cars have been damaged by stones on that same day on Road 5. The latter only appeared after the car accident got a lot of media coverage as a “terrorist act”, and the Israeli prime minister Benyamin Natanyahu announced, after the boys’ arrest, that he “caught the terrorists that did it”. Other “witnesses” include the police and the Shabak, who were not even present at that location at the time. It is not clear whether the 61 “witnesses” have been properly questioned and their claims verified with, for example, hospital admission data, or even if the alleged damage to their vehicles has been photographed or otherwise documented. Such information is not even available to the boys’ attorneys.
If the boys are convicted, this case would set a legal precedent which would allow the Israeli military to convict any Palestinian child or youngster for attempted murder in cases of stone-throwing.
The boys are now 16-17 years old. If the Israeli military get their way, the boys would only return to their homes and their families at the age of 41 – at best. Five young lives ruined with no evidence of their guilt is a spit in the face to our common principles of justice as human beings.
WHAT’S WRONG WITH THIS?
Almost every stage of this case that could go wrong, did. Local and international law has been mostly dismissed; principles of justice barely fading in the horizon; respect for human beings non-existent.
- The Hares Boys, as well as thousands of other Palestinian youngsters, are treated in the Israeli military court system as adults. According to international human rights law in general, and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child in particular, adults are people over 18 years of age. Israel treats even 9-year-olds as adults.
- The racist system of “justice”: no matter the alleged crime, Palestinians are forced to go through the military courts and are tried under military law, while Israelis fall into the civil court system for the same crimes.
- Violently arresting children at night without giving any explanation to their families about the reasons behind it, nor informing them about their children’s whereabouts goes against Israel’s own laws which state that minors are to be accompanied by an adult family member when detained or arrested.
- The denial of lawyer for several days (in some cases weeks) after detention also accounts as a major violation of Israel’s own rules.
- Children being put into solitary confinement for days on end is a form of torture; It is a severe punishment before the verdict.
- Abusive interrogations of scared minors is considered torture.
- The boys were arrested despite a total lack of evidence against them and condemned by the Israeli media as “terrorists”, which goes against the universal presumption of innocence (innocent until found guilty) and delivers a guilty verdict in the highly bombastic public trial, putting pressure on the judges to do likewise.
For more detailed accounts of the initial arrests and interrogations, please see IWPS Human Rights Reports from the ground:
HRR447: Arrest of 10 adolescents in Hares, Salfit (15 March 2013)
HRR448: Arrests of 3 more adolescents in Hares, Salfit: A (17 March 2013)
HRR451: Interrogation of a 16-year-old (21 March 2013)
HRR452: Arbitrary arrests of minors (21 March 2013)
HRR458: Military court hearing for Hares arrest (9 April 2013)
HRR461: Arrest of three adolescents in Hares (9 April 2013)
Images used: Michael Loadenthal and angrywhitekid, both under a Creative Commons licence.
Pingback: Smoke and mirrorsLiberal Democrat Friends of Palestine | Liberal Democrat Friends of Palestine
Pingback: Support the Hares boys this Prisoners’ Day | International Solidarity Movement
please post a reblog button? it is very helpful
One day they will pay for the crimes that were committed against the Palestinian People. Most of the people, who committed crimes
against people, such as Jews, during the second world war, were caught. That time will come.
Justice will come. It is just around the corner.
You see, this argument is flawed. In many Western societies, a child can be tried as an adult and treated as such, if the crime is considered a serious felony. I know this because I’ve experienced it myself with my own government. At 12, I caused grievous bodily harm on a boy of the same age, and the British government had detained, interrogated, and trialled me as an adult BECAUSE OF THE CRIME I COMMITTED. If you are stupid enough to attack someone, regardless of your age, you better be prepared to receive the same treatment from the authorities. Simple as.
How is the argument that no state – especially no occupying state – can torture children flawed?
A crime is not a crime until it is proven that it was committed by the person accused of committing it. Which was never the case with the Hares Boys, who were accused without no evidence and incarcerated for 2 years now, attending military (!) court “hearings” where the only side being heard is that of the accuser.
Additionally, various human rights organisations and international bodies have repeated time and time again, that imprisonment is the last resort when it comes to children. Torture – including solitary confinement – is completely unacceptable in any case.
Supporting oppression wherever it occurs is a sign of our failure as human beings, let alone our own devised systems of “justice” that serves only the oppressor.
Nothing Suprises me eny more regarding the brutalities the people of the occupied land have to endure please keep me up to date.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please see the latest developments: https://haresboys.wordpress.com/sentence/
I am from Vancouver,Canada and I wanted to say that the Hares Boys should be freed, not sentenced to fifteen years in prison.This is the kind of thing that happened to Black People in the Southern States in the USA during the 1950s and 60s and also in apartheid South Africa.
This is Israeli apartheid and it should be condemned by all civilized people in the world.These five young people are innocent and they were tortured while in prison.This is a travesty of justice and Canada and the USA should be condemned for supporting these atrocities by the Israeli gov’t against the Palestinian Teenagers from Hares.There can be no peace with Israeli apartheid.
Thank you Stan for your heartfelt words. A travesty of justice – this is indeed what is happening to the five kids from Hares village as well as thousands of other Palestinian children living under Israeli military colonial rule. It is a shame that self-professed “democracies” in the Global North do not stand up and say “Enough”, and stop doing business with apartheid.
The boys have been made scapegoats to ameliorate the hatred and irrational fear of “stones” that the zionist government pushes and incites. The woman must feel very guilty for her careless driving that nearly killed her child and has covered her mistake with the mantel of the “innocent victim” of children’s “stones.” The truck driver said right after the accident that there were no stones thrown that he could see, and, indeed there were none. A dragnet scooped up the kids and the most vulnerable children’s lives have been ruined by Biton’s lies!
Justice? There is no peace without justice.
Pingback: UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention slams Israeli human rights breaches in Hares Boy’s case, demands his immediate release | Samidoun: Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network
Pingback: UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention slams Nazi human rights breaches in Hares Boys case | SHOAH
Pingback: 10 years in prison for a crime that never happened | Hares Boys
Pingback: LosChicos de Hares: 10 años en la cárcel por un crimen que nunca ocurrió | Palestina en el corazón